The following are the Superior Court Recommendations for California’s Runoff Election 11/4/2008
ElectionForum.org ranks every aspect of a candidate’s record on a scale of 1 (most activist) to 10 (most constructionist).
Nothing is overlooked, from a judge’s rulings to on-the-record statements to American Bar Association ratings. We also look at their stated positions and contributions as well as who’s endorsing them.
Finally, each judge’s career is considered from a bird’s-eye view. Experience. Integrity. Commitment to community. We even personally talk to the candidates.
Ratings for all candidates—Judicial Activist vs. Strict Constructionist
Judicial Index Average
|
| Judicial Activist |
Strict Constructionist |
- Positions
- Contributions
- Rulings
- Statements
Qualifications
|
| Unqualified |
Very Qualified |
- Experience
- Reputation
- Integrity
- American Bar
Association ratings
Below are ratings for the 2008 judicial candidates listed by county. Please note each judicial candidate’s numerical rating is a combination of the judicial index average and the qualifications ratings you see above.
Alameda County
Superior Court Judge; County of Alameda; Seat 9
• Phil Daly (Recommend as the lesser of two poor choices—Rating average: 4)
• Dennis Hayashi (Do not recommend—Rating average: 1)
Fresno County
Superior Court Judge; County of Fresno; Office 10
• Jim Kelley (Recommend—Rating average: 6)
• Douglas O. Treisman (Do not recommend—Rating average: 4)
Kern County
Superior Court Judge; County of Kern; Office 30
• Holly N. Mitchell (Recommend—Rating average: 8)
• Charles R. “Chip” Brehmer (Recommend—Rating average: 8)
Los Angeles County
Superior Court Judge; County of Los Angeles; Office 72
• Steven A. Simons
(Recommend—Rating average: 8)
• Hilleri Grossman Merritt (Do not recommend—Rating average: 4)
Superior Court Judge; County of Los Angeles; Office 82
• Thomas Rubinson (Recommend—Rating average: 8)
• Cynthia Loo (Do not recommend—Rating average: 2)
Superior Court Judge; County of Los Angeles; Office 84
• Pat Connolly (Recommend—Rating average: 6)
• Lori-Ann C. Jones (Do not recommend—Rating average: 2)
Superior Court Judge; County of Los Angeles; Office 94
• Michael J. O'Gara (Recommend—Rating average: 7)
• C. Edward Mack (Do not recommend—Rating average: 5)
Superior Court Judge; County of Los Angeles; Office 154
• Michael V. Jesic (Recommend—Rating average: 9)
• Rocky L. Crabb (Do not recommend—Rating average: 4)
Monterey County
Superior Court Judge; County of Monterey; Seat 2
• Mark Hood (Recommend—Rating average: 6)
• Todd Hornik (Do not recommend—Rating average: 4)
Orange County
Superior Court Judge; County of Orange; Office 12
• Kermit Marsh (Strongly recommend—Rating average: 8)
• Debra Carrillo (Do not recommend—Rating average: 4)
San Francisco County
Superior Court Judge; County of San Francisco; Seat 12
• Thomas Mellon (Recommend—Rating average: 6)
• Gerardo C. Sandoval (Do not recommend—Rating average: 2)
San Joaquin County
Superior Court Judge; County of San Joaquin; Office 10
• Phil Urie (Strongly recommend—Rating average: 9)
• James M. Morris (Do not recommend—Rating average: 4)
Santa Barbara County
Superior Court Judge; County of Santa Barbara; Office 5
• Jed Beebe (Recommend—Rating average: 7)
• John Mackinnon (Do not recommend—Rating average: 5)
Santa Clara County
Superior Court Judge; County of Santa Clara; Office 8
• Lane Liroff (Recommend—Rating average: 7)
• Diane Ritchie (Do not recommend—Rating average: 2)
|